top of page

Are women becoming more powerful with AI, or just more productive?

10 minutes ago
6 min read

I can name a dozen ways AI has made me faster, and I find it much harder to name a single way it has made me more influential, which is either a reflection on AI or a reflection on me, and I suspect the answer is a bit of both. So the question I keep returning to, and the one this piece tries to explore, is a simple one: are women in our industry being encouraged to use AI to grow their power and influence, or simply to become more efficient at the jobs they already have?


The time we save doesn't stay saved

Earlier this year, researchers at UC Berkeley's Haas School of Business published what they had learned from following around 200 employees at a US tech company for eight months as they adopted generative AI. The people using it didn't work less. They worked faster, took on a broader range of tasks and let work spill into more hours of the day. The interesting bit for me is: Expectations for speed rose on their own, through what became visible and normal in everyday work rather than through any instruction from leadership. An executive at the workforce analytics firm ActivTrak described the same pattern to the Wall Street Journal, noting that the efficiency is real but the capacity it frees up gets put straight back to work.


Why this lands differently for women

If the productivity trap applied equally to everyone, this would be a story about work culture. The research suggests it is also a story about gender, and three findings stood out to me.


The first is about encouragement, which is the word at the heart of my question. In McKinsey and LeanIn.Org's Women in the Workplace 2025 report, only 21 percent of entry-level women said their managers had encouraged them to use AI tools, compared with 33 percent of men at the same level. That gap matters more than it might seem, because the same report found that people who are encouraged to use AI are more than 50 percent more likely to actually do so.


The second is about how women are judged when they do use it. A study published in Harvard Business Review asked engineers to review identical pieces of code, and when reviewers believed AI had been involved, they rated the author as less competent. The penalty was 13 percent for women and 6 percent for men, and it rose to 26 percent when the reviewers were men who didn't use AI themselves. A separate UK study of identical CVs found a similar pattern, with the researcher observing that men who use AI tend to have their effort questioned, while women have their integrity questioned.


The third is exposure. According to the International Labour Organization, the jobs at highest risk of automation make up 9.6 percent of women's employment in high-income countries, against 3.5 percent of men's. I don't have figures for commerce media specifically, but it isn't hard to think of roles in our industry, in campaign operations, trafficking and reporting, that might sit uncomfortably close to that line.


Put together, it is a narrow path. Women are encouraged less, judged more harshly when they use AI and more exposed if they fall behind, and in that environment quietly becoming more productive starts to look like the safest option on offer. It is perhaps no surprise that a review of studies covering more than 140,000 people, led by researchers from Berkeley, Stanford and Harvard, found women around 20 percent less likely than men to use tools like ChatGPT and Claude, and more likely to see using them as a kind of cheating.


Where power might actually come from

I asked Charina Lumley at Douglas for her perspective, and her answers moved my thinking somewhere more useful. Drawing on her years in both retail and tech, she put it this way:

"Technology alone rarely creates competitive advantages. Rather, it's our ability to connect technology to real business problems that makes the difference."

At Douglas, she told me, the team sits on enormous amounts of customer data, increasingly sophisticated measurement and now AI, and yet the questions that matter are still commercial ones: how to help brand partners grow, how to improve the customer experience, how to demonstrate incremental value. Her team talks about not necessarily needing to be the most technical person in the room, while still understanding the technology well enough to challenge it, shape how it is applied and translate it into business value. Their work on a data clean room proposition is her example, where the value comes less from the technology itself than from showing how media investment changes customer behaviour and sales, and turning that into stronger partnerships.


This helped me see the two halves of my own question more clearly. Productivity is about doing the existing job faster. Influence seems to come from being the person who connects what the technology can do with what the business actually needs, and who can explain why it matters to the people making decisions.


Not every hour belongs to work

Charina's second answer challenged the framing I started with, and I found it harder to read than I expected.

"I would challenge the assumption that every hour we save through AI needs to be reinvested into our professional lives."

She pointed to the responsibilities many women carry outside work, from young families and ageing parents to the invisible mental load of keeping everything organised, and suggested that one of the greatest rewards of becoming more efficient might be more capacity for life beyond the job. As she put it, leaders need to challenge the idea that productivity gains should automatically turn into higher expectations, and think instead about how those gains can make careers more sustainable.

Read next to the Berkeley research, this landed uncomfortably close to home. Nobody asked those employees to fill their saved time with more work, and nobody has asked me either. Some of the trap, it turns out, is one I build for myself.


Deciding where the saved hours go

The most practical idea I can offer is a simple one. Every time AI saves an hour, that hour goes somewhere, and it usually goes one of three ways. It can quietly disappear into more of the same work, which is what happens by default. It can go into the kind of work that builds influence, such as the conversation with a partner, the business case only a person can make, or showing the team something new. Or it can go back into life outside work.


I don't keep a spreadsheet of this, and I suspect very few people would. What I do is much simpler. I block time in my calendar for meditation and for walks, and I treat those blocks as seriously as any meeting. The same habit works for the second kind of hour too: a block for thinking time, or for the conversation that moves something forward, is a small way of deciding where the time goes before the inbox decides for us.


Using AI out loud

Charina's final piece of advice was to stay curious and experiment without waiting for a big AI project or feeling pressure to become a technical expert overnight. She suggested spending an afternoon learning to vibe-code a simple website, or trying AI on a problem that has been sitting at the back of the mind for a while, and then doing something many of us skip:

"Share what you've learned generously. When you help others become more capable, you're not just demonstrating your own expertise, but building influence."

Sharing the method, the shortcuts and the judgment involved turns AI use into evidence of expertise rather than a suspected shortcut. It may also help with the penalty itself, since the research suggests the harshest judges of AI use were people who weren't using it, so every colleague who learns something from us is one fewer person inclined to judge.


So, powerful or productive?

For most women in commerce media right now, I think the honest answer is productive. Power doesn't seem to arrive by default with the tools. It comes from deliberately moving some of the saved time into the work that shapes decisions, from being open about how the work got done, and, if Charina is right, from protecting some of that time for the rest of life too.


I would love to hear how this looks for the women in our community. If anyone tries blocking their time this way, or has a story of AI genuinely changing their influence rather than just their output, please share it with us, as it may well become the next piece in this series.


Sources

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Inside Turkey's Retail Media Revolution

By Ana Laura Zain, WRMC Co-founder and CMO at Pentaleap Last week, Emma and I boarded a plane to Istanbul, filled with excitement and anticipation. We were there to join the brilliant Kına Demirel and

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page